Constructive criticism please! » Analityka marketingowa » Forum
Forum

Forum



ПоискПоиск   Users   Rejestracja   Wejście
Dzisiaj: 01.06.2025 - 16:07:34
Strony:  1  

Constructive criticism please!

Ogłoszenie

.
AutorWiadomość

earn4me

users




Statystyka:
Wiadomości: 31
Rejestracja: 02 mar 2013, 3:08

I like it! But something about the drums... just not enough presence it seems. The highs seem lost a bit to me, especially on the hard crash cymbals. The dynamics just don't seem quite right... that's the only thing I hear that I think would make it a killer tune. Maybe open it up more "stereo" in the mix... it all seems to be pretty centered. That might be what's holding the drums back. The song is awesome!! Great guitar and lyrical work. Thanks for posting. :) Jedi

---------------------
Wiadomość # 1 11.10.22 - 11:34:40
RE: Constructive criticism please!

Daguchna

users




Statystyka:
Wiadomości: 109
Rejestracja: 19 lis 2009, 23:14

Thanks Jedi! I agree with the presence issue. That's the biggest roadblock I'm hitting. When I play the song loud it just KILLS my ears. There is something about the high end that is very straining at high volumes. I've tenaciously compared it to commercial recordings that I like and they don't seem to have the same effect. I use a frequency analyzer to see what is causing it but my spectrum matches pretty closely with the commercial stuff. Finally I just got frustrated and cut some highs on the master mix. It seemed to help the piercing effect but I also lost some presence. Anyone have any ideas on how I should attack this issue? Thanks!

---------------------
Wiadomość # 2 11.10.22 - 11:46:04
RE: Constructive criticism please!

Stig

users




Statystyka:
Wiadomości: 21
Rejestracja: 12 sie 2010, 14:50

I like a bit of ,"Metal" and some of the heavy stuff and this is superb.Great voice,playing and construction and the song kicks the proverbial :D Took the liberty of giving it a quick Re-master.If you no like,me will run away and hide<grin> :O)

---------------------
Wiadomość # 3 11.10.22 - 11:55:17
RE: Constructive criticism please!

atomówka96

users




Statystyka:
Wiadomości: 1687
Rejestracja: 02 maja 2016, 9:45

So Shep: Please do tell... what exactly DID YOU DO???? I'm sure all of us can learn a great deal from this.... :) Jedi

---------------------
Wiadomość # 4 11.10.22 - 12:05:20
RE: Constructive criticism please!

mateuszNF

users




Statystyka:
Wiadomości: 97
Rejestracja: 27 lis 2014, 11:22

Very cool tune. Excellent playing. Very well written. Love all the drops happening everywhere in the chorus. Heavy, clean, catchy. This track is a winner. Very nice job. Great vocals too!

---------------------
wkrótce tu będzie mój podpis i link do mojego bloga!
Wiadomość # 5 11.10.22 - 12:15:12
RE: Constructive criticism please!

Kurdeweźwyjdź

users




Statystyka:
Wiadomości: 313
Rejestracja: 24 lip 2021, 17:54

Great tune! Great vocals and guitar playing. Excellent mix and mastering. I don't like the sound of the drums at all, although the guy can play.

---------------------
Wiadomość # 6 11.10.22 - 12:22:39
RE: Constructive criticism please!

p1fan

users




Statystyka:
Wiadomości: 16
Rejestracja: 11 kwie 2008, 9:16

Really great stuff. Awesome vocals. Guitars and bass sound great. There is something with the drums that strikes me as a little "programmed" The tones are good, and the parts are well written, but over time they begin to sound like they are missing maybe a some dynamics, or even just some subtle varieties here and there to keep the listener on their toes a bit. Its not an glaring problem, but its something that I noticed. But overall awesome job!

---------------------
Wiadomość # 7 11.10.22 - 12:31:04
RE: Constructive criticism please!

pitersid

users




Statystyka:
Wiadomości: 29
Rejestracja: 02 mar 2007, 19:20

heavy and catchy great vocals nice dynamic movement mix seems low mid heavy pretty original sounding /oaktree

---------------------
Może to Twój urok... może to Photoshop...!?!
Wiadomość # 8 11.10.22 - 12:38:02
RE: Constructive criticism please!
Insert time : Poprzedni temat
Strony:  1  

Administrator zabronił gościom odpowiadać na wiadomości! Aby się zarejestrować, kliknij link: rejestr


Uczestnicy